Кбит/с
| Тест по среднему значению разницы исходного и кодированного сигнала | |||||||||
| 0.5% от ИС | Название кодера | Режим работы | СРС | Макс. РС
| |||||
| 19,33320521 | Lame v.3.61 | Fast mode | 491,3825668 | 8209 | |||||
| 19,31272829 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho off | 491,9035705 | 7087 | |||||
| 19,31071882 | Lame DLL v.3.83 | Fast mode | 491,9547579 | 7246 | |||||
| 19,09233752 | Lame v.3.85 | Fast mode | 497,5818173 | 8378 | |||||
| 19,08169107 | Lame v.3.84 | Fast mode | 497,8594383 | 8378 | |||||
| 18,58008201 | Lame v.3.84 | New code fast mode | 511,300219 | 6976 | |||||
| 18,58008201 | Lame v.3.84 | Old code fast mode | 511,300219 | 6976 | |||||
| 18,27910915 | Lame v.3.85 | New code fast mode | 519,7189821 | 7146 | |||||
| 18,27910915 | Lame v.3.85 | Old code fast mode | 519,7189821 | 7146 | |||||
| 17,33134275 | SCMPX v.1.5.1 | Fast mode | 548,1398723 | 17472 | |||||
| 17,08894641 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho on | 555,9149037 | 8930 | |||||
| 16,19164251 | Lame v.3.61 | High Quality | 586,72244 | 8935 | |||||
| 16,18692432 | PULSE MP3 Master v.2.0 | Fast mode | 586,8934586 | 12803 | |||||
| 16,02443383 | Lame DLL v.3.83 | High Quality | 592,8446583 | 7844 | |||||
| 15,98691878 | GOGO DLL v.2.3 | 594,235833 | 8055 | ||||||
| 15,94752472 | Lame v.3.85 | High Quality | 595,7037326 | 8146 | |||||
| 15,94477403 | Lame v.3.84 | High Quality | 595,8064993 | 9082 | |||||
| 15,38943237 | Blade Encoder DLL v.0.91 | 617,3067187 | 11910 | ||||||
| 15,23332299 | Lame v.3.84 | New code high quality | 623,6328087 | 7661 | |||||
| 15,23332299 | Lame v.3.84 | Old code high quality | 623,6328087 | 7661 | |||||
| 15,21765619 | PULSE MP3 Master v.2.0 | Standard mode | 624,2748476 | 10623 | |||||
| 15,06778265 | SCMPX v.1.5.1 | Standard mode | 630,4842735 | 11417 | |||||
| 14,46629474 | Lame v.3.85 | New code high quality | 656,6989108 | 7852 | |||||
| 14,46629474 | Lame v.3.85 | Old code high quality | 656,6989108 | 7852 | |||||
| 14,19827543 | Lame v.3.61 | 669,0953451 | 9681 | ||||||
| 13,86183129 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Hi Frequency Mode | 685,3351336 | 7642 | |||||
| 13,79721386 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Standard mode | 688,5448104 | 8681 | |||||
| 13,72915367 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho off | 691,9581662 | 8654 | |||||
| 13,72915367 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho on | 691,9581662 | 8654 | |||||
| 13,43960686 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.5b | Fast mode | 706,8659149 | 8562 | |||||
| 13,43960686 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.4 | Fast mode | 706,8659149 | 8562 | |||||
| 13,1565012 | Audioactive Production Studio v.2.0.4j | Fast mode | 722,076474 | 8439 | |||||
| 13,07647838 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.5b | High Quality | 726,4952937 | 8581 | |||||
| 13,07647838 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.4 | High Quality | 726,4952937 | 8581 | |||||
| 13,07647838 | Audioactive Production Studio v.2.0.4j | High Quality | 726,4952937 | 8581 | |||||
| 12,79474045 | Microsoft WMA V7 | 742,4925922 | 9980 | ||||||
| 12,46481801 | Fraunhofer Radium MP3 codec v.1.263 | Fast mode | 762,1451024 | 9707 | |||||
| 12,38898225 | Fraunhofer Radium MP3 codec v.1.263 | High Quality | 766,8103649 | 9049 | |||||
| 12,31260681 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Hi Frequency Mode | 771,5669109 | 8628 | |||||
| 12,30863731 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Standard mode | 771,8157391 | 8630 | |||||
| 10,23767965 | Blade Encoder DLL v.0.93.4 | 927,9446442 | 32066 | ||||||
| 9,860095202 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | LTP mode | 963,4795411 | 12644 | |||||
| 9,855245473 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | Standard mode | 963,9536657 | 12644 | |||||
| 9,851361882 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | TNS mode | 964,3336742 | 16768 | |||||
| 9,847455603 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | LTP&TNS mode | 964,7162052 | 15478 | |||||
| 9,045794062 | XingMPEG Encoder v.2.20 | 1050,211837 | 10614 | ||||||
| 1,308744771 | LQT Liquid v.4.0 | 7258,86377 | 53377 | ||||||
| 1,288894363 | LQT Liquid v.4.0 | 7370,658352 | 60820 |
|
Тест по среднему значению разницы формы исходного и кодированного сигнала |
||||
|
0.5% от ИС |
Название кодера |
Режим работы |
СРФР |
Макс. РФС |
| 26,8268572 | Lame v.3.61 | Fast mode | 465,950965 | 10409 |
| 26,81249238 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho off | 466,2005987 | 11097 |
| 26,79384428 | Lame DLL v.3.83 | Fast mode | 466,525067 | 10660 |
| 26,61515469 | Lame v.3.85 | Fast mode | 469,6572365 | 9017 |
| 26,59950897 | Lame v.3.84 | Fast mode | 469,9334869 | 9017 |
| 25,97684666 | Lame v.3.84 | New code fast mode | 481,1977436 | 7693 |
| 25,97684666 | Lame v.3.84 | Old code fast mode | 481,1977436 | 7693 |
| 25,66935475 | Lame v.3.85 | New code fast mode | 486,9619872 | 7693 |
| 25,66935475 | Lame v.3.85 | Old code fast mode | 486,9619872 | 7693 |
| 25,15029503 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho on | 497,0120623 | 9674 |
| 24,90373852 | GOGO DLL v.2.3 | 501,9326713 | 13543 | |
| 24,82736949 | Lame v.3.61 | High Quality | 503,476617 | 8479 |
| 24,73159684 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.5b | Fast mode | 505,4263209 | 10783 |
| 24,73159684 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.4 | Fast mode | 505,4263209 | 10783 |
| 24,67273014 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.5b | High Quality | 506,6322183 | 12468 |
| 24,67273014 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.4 | High Quality | 506,6322183 | 12468 |
| 24,67273014 | Audioactive Production Studio v.2.0.4j | High Quality | 506,6322183 | 12468 |
| 24,66673069 | Lame v.3.85 | High Quality | 506,7554415 | 10497 |
| 24,65927437 | Lame v.3.84 | High Quality | 506,9086711 | 10497 |
| 24,65534485 | Lame DLL v.3.83 | High Quality | 506,9894611 | 10497 |
| 24,56777951 | Lame v.3.61 | 508,7964907 | 8465 | |
| 24,3783777 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho off | 512,74946 | 10749 |
| 24,3783777 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho on | 512,74946 | 10749 |
| 24,32953279 | Audioactive Production Studio v.2.0.4j | Fast mode | 513,7788755 | 10764 |
| 23,81776581 | Fraunhofer Radium MP3 codec v.1.263 | High Quality | 524,8183268 | 11907 |
| 23,71474145 | Lame v.3.84 | New code high quality | 527,0983041 | 8631 |
| 23,71474145 | Lame v.3.84 | Old code high quality | 527,0983041 | 8631 |
| 23,5816646 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Hi Frequency Mode | 530,0728432 | 11251 |
| 23,3824541 | Microsoft WMA V7 | 534,5888822 | 11164 | |
| 23,37319806 | Fraunhofer Radium MP3 codec v.1.263 | Fast mode | 534,8005851 | 13794 |
| 23,33454472 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Standard mode | 535,6864748 | 11251 |
| 23,0168072 | Lame v.3.85 | New code high quality | 543,0814053 | 8837 |
| 23,0168072 | Lame v.3.85 | Old code high quality | 543,0814053 | 8837 |
| 22,2162858 | XingMPEG Encoder v.2.20 | 562,6503058 | 13270 | |
| 22,0313494 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Hi Frequency Mode | 567,3733268 | 10545 |
| 22,02521552 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Standard mode | 567,5313365 | 10520 |
| 21,10215353 | SCMPX v.1.5.1 | Standard mode | 592,3566039 | 13846 |
| 20,93864054 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | Standard mode | 596,9824056 | 10381 |
| 20,93589315 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | LTP mode | 597,0607467 | 10381 |
| 20,9222445 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | TNS mode | 597,45024 | 12418 |
| 20,91632424 | Blade Encoder DLL v.0.93.4 | 597,6193454 | 13989 | |
| 20,91089455 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | LTP&TNS mode | 597,7745222 | 12418 |
| 20,821569 | SCMPX v.1.5.1 | Fast mode | 600,3390043 | 24998 |
| 19,43248411 | Blade Encoder DLL v.0.91 | 643,2528097 | 14484 | |
| 18,74913285 | PULSE MP3 Master v.2.0 | Standard mode | 666,6975002 | 13398 |
| 17,92471428 | PULSE MP3 Master v.2.0 | Fast mode | 697,3611857 | 18112 |
| 4,76083188 | LQT Liquid v.4.0 | 2625,591559 | 45430 | |
| 4,656682128 | LQT Liquid v.4.0 | 2684,314638 | 45646 |
|
% от ИС |
Название кодера |
Режим работы |
% от лидера |
| 46,16006241 | Lame v.3.61 | Fast mode | |
| 46,12522067 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho off | 99,9245% |
| 46,1045631 | Lame DLL v.3.83 | Fast mode | 99,8798% |
| 45,70749221 | Lame v.3.85 | Fast mode | 99,0196% |
| 45,68120005 | Lame v.3.84 | Fast mode | 98,9626% |
| 44,55692867 | Lame v.3.84 | New code fast mode | 96,5270% |
| 44,55692867 | Lame v.3.84 | Old code fast mode | 96,5270% |
| 43,9484639 | Lame v.3.85 | New code fast mode | 95,2088% |
| 43,9484639 | Lame v.3.85 | Old code fast mode | 95,2088% |
| 42,23924144 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho on | 91,5060% |
| 41,019012 | Lame v.3.61 | High Quality | 88,8626% |
| 40,8906573 | GOGO DLL v.2.3 | 88,5845% | |
| 40,67977869 | Lame DLL v.3.83 | High Quality | 88,1277% |
| 40,6142554 | Lame v.3.85 | High Quality | 87,9857% |
| 40,6040484 | Lame v.3.84 | High Quality | 87,9636% |
| 38,94806444 | Lame v.3.84 | New code high quality | 84,3761% |
| 38,94806444 | Lame v.3.84 | Old code high quality | 84,3761% |
| 38,76605495 | Lame v.3.61 | 83,9818% | |
| 38,1712037 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.5b | Fast mode | 82,6931% |
| 38,1712037 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.4 | Fast mode | 82,6931% |
| 38,15291174 | SCMPX v.1.5.1 | Fast mode | 82,6535% |
| 38,10753137 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho off | 82,5552% |
| 38,10753137 | GOGO v.2.35.1 | Psycho on | 82,5552% |
| 37,74920852 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.5b | High Quality | 81,7789% |
| 37,74920852 | Audioactive Production Studio v.1.5.4 | High Quality | 81,7789% |
| 37,74920852 | Audioactive Production Studio v.2.0.4j | High Quality | 81,7789% |
| 37,486034 | Audioactive Production Studio v.2.0.4j | Fast mode | 81,2088% |
| 37,48310194 | Lame v.3.85 | New code high quality | 81,2025% |
| 37,48310194 | Lame v.3.85 | Old code high quality | 81,2025% |
| 37,44349589 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Hi Frequency Mode | 81,1166% |
| 37,13175857 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Standard mode | 80,4413% |
| 36,20674806 | Fraunhofer Radium MP3 codec v.1.263 | High Quality | 78,4374% |
| 36,17719454 | Microsoft WMA V7 | 78,3734% | |
| 36,16993618 | SCMPX v.1.5.1 | Standard mode | 78,3576% |
| 35,83801608 | Fraunhofer Radium MP3 codec v.1.263 | Fast mode | 77,6386% |
| 34,82191648 | Blade Encoder DLL v.0.91 | 75,4373% | |
| 34,3439562 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Hi Frequency Mode | 74,4019% |
| 34,33385283 | XingMP3 Encoder v.1.5 | Standard mode | 74,3800% |
| 34,1116386 | PULSE MP3 Master v.2.0 | Fast mode | 73,8986% |
| 33,96678904 | PULSE MP3 Master v.2.0 | Standard mode | 73,5848% |
| 31,26207986 | XingMPEG Encoder v.2.20 | 67,7254% | |
| 31,15400389 | Blade Encoder DLL v.0.93.4 | 67,4913% | |
| 30,79598836 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | LTP mode | 66,7157% |
| 30,79388601 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | Standard mode | 66,7111% |
| 30,77360639 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | TNS mode | 66,6672% |
| 30,75835015 | Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 | LTP&TNS mode | 66,6341% |
| 6,069576651 | LQT Liquid v.4.0 | 13,1490% | |
| 5,94557649 | LQT Liquid v.4.0 | 12,8803% |
Радикальных изменений по сравнению с предыдущими битрейтами не произошло. Вперед вырвался Lame v.3.61, но отставание от него Lame 3.83 очень маленькое - 0,1%. В эти же 0,1% попал и GOGO 2.35.1 с отключенной психоакустической моделью ISO. Следом традиционно расположились Lame 3.84 и Lame 3.85 в быстрых режимах, туда же подтянулись и результаты высококачественного режима (кроме Lame 3.85 VBR). IIS Fraunhofer код снова отстал до уровня ~83% Lame. Также заметно улучшил свои показатели SCMPX VBR в быстром режиме - 78,3% Lame.
WMA V7 продолжил свое отставание - на этот раз до уровня 78,3% Lame. IIS Fraunhofer "празднует" победу.
Freeware AAC Encoder v.0.61 отстал до уровня 66,7% Lame - предположение о плохой масштабируемости получило подтверждение. Ну а упоминать масштабируемость Liquifier Pro v.4 вообще не хочется.
VBR так и не смог подняться выше своего статического собрата - возникает закономерный вопрос: а зачем тогда он вообще нужен?
